For one season, Eric Lauer became the answer nobody in Toronto expected — and perhaps the one the Blue Jays aren’t sure they want to keep.
After losing the entire 2024 campaign to injury and uncertainty, the 30-year-old left-hander arrived in Toronto on a minor league deal with little fanfare and even fewer expectations. By April, he was back in the majors. By midseason, he was indispensable. By October, he was one of the most effective pitchers on the roster.
And yet, despite producing his best MLB season in years, Eric Lauer’s future with the Toronto Blue Jays suddenly feels fragile.
Lauer made 28 appearances for Toronto in 2025, including 15 starts, and delivered results that far exceeded what the organization could have reasonably hoped for. A 3.18 ERA. 102 strikeouts. Reliable innings in both the rotation and the bullpen. At times, he was the stabilizer when injuries, workload management, or inconsistency threatened to derail the pitching staff.
On a team with postseason ambitions, Lauer didn’t just fill innings — he mattered.
That’s what makes the current conversation so uncomfortable.
Despite his resurgence, Lauer is arbitration-eligible for only one more season before hitting free agency. And with Toronto aggressively adding arms this offseason, the writing on the wall is becoming harder to ignore. According to Sportsnet’s Nick Ashbourne, the Blue Jays are unlikely to offer Lauer an extension beyond next year — a projection that has quietly gained traction inside league circles.
“Lauer exceeded all reasonable expectations by a significant margin in 2025,” Ashbourne wrote, “but some skepticism is warranted considering it was his first strong MLB campaign since 2022.”
That skepticism cuts to the heart of the dilemma Toronto faces.
Was Lauer’s 2025 performance a genuine rebirth — or a perfectly timed peak? Front offices are paid to ask questions fans don’t want to hear, and the Blue Jays are no exception. Buying high on a pitcher who profiles long-term as a swingman or long reliever is rarely comfortable business, especially for a club that has spent heavily to fortify its staff with established names.
Toronto’s offseason strategy tells its own story. The Blue Jays have poured significant resources into pitching, stacking depth and star power with the intent of contending immediately. In that environment, versatility can be both a blessing and a curse. Lauer’s ability to bounce between roles made him valuable in 2025 — but it may also be the reason he’s viewed as expendable.
Ashbourne pointed to another potential complication: Lauer’s own priorities.
“Lauer could also be resistant to signing with a team that’s shown reluctance to use him as a starter when other options arise,” he wrote, suggesting the left-hander may want to position himself as a back-of-the-rotation candidate heading into free agency after the 2026 season.
That matters.
For a pitcher who resurrected his career by proving he could still start, being pigeonholed into long relief may feel like a step backward. Lauer has shown he can handle both assignments, but history suggests players rarely accept reduced roles quietly when free agency looms.
From Toronto’s perspective, the logic is cold but consistent. The front office has to weigh long-term payroll flexibility against short-term production. Extending a pitcher entering his early 30s after one standout season carries real risk, particularly when that season followed multiple years of injury and inconsistency.
From Lauer’s perspective, the timing couldn’t be more frustrating.
This was supposed to be the redemption arc — the year that reset the narrative and earned him security. Instead, it may simply have bought him visibility. If the Blue Jays allow him to walk after next season, Lauer will hit the open market with fresh credibility, but no guarantees.
What complicates matters further is how impactful he truly was. Lauer didn’t thrive in a sheltered role. He was trusted with real responsibility. He stabilized games. He gave Toronto options. On a roster chasing October success, that kind of reliability is supposed to be rewarded.
But baseball isn’t sentimental.
The Blue Jays are operating like a franchise with one eye on the present and one eye firmly on the ledger. With so many pitching additions already in place, extending Lauer may feel redundant — or worse, inefficient. That doesn’t mean he failed. It may simply mean he succeeded at the wrong time.
As 2026 approaches, the pressure will quietly shift onto both sides. Can Lauer replicate his 2025 form and force Toronto’s hand? Or will regression, role changes, and roster congestion make the decision easier for the front office?
For now, nothing is official. No goodbye has been announced. No bridge has been burned. But in a sport where opportunity windows slam shut without warning, the signs are unmistakable.
Eric Lauer did everything the Blue Jays asked of him — and more. Whether that’s enough to keep him in Toronto may say as much about the modern economics of baseball as it does about his arm.
Sometimes, even your best season isn’t enough to secure your future.
Leave a Reply