As the 2025 calendar winds down, Major League Baseball’s offseason enters its most critical stretch — the period that separates true contenders from teams merely trying to stay competitive while staying under budget. The defending American League champion Toronto Blue Jays have positioned themselves as one of the most aggressive clubs on the market, signaling their intent to compete for another title. So far, their acquisitions have focused primarily on pitching, with the signings of Dylan Cease, submarine reliever Tyler Rogers, and Korean league star Cody Ponce.
While the mound has been strengthened, Toronto’s offense has yet to see the same urgency. President and CEO Mark Shapiro has been linked to Chicago Cubs outfielder Kyle Tucker, arguably the most productive and expensive hitter still available. Tucker is widely estimated to command a $402 million, 10-year contract, and the longer Toronto hesitates, the greater the chance another team swoops in. Now, sources suggest that an unexpected American League East rival could capitalize on the Blue Jays’ caution, potentially stealing Tucker from their grasp.
The Baltimore Orioles, a team that won just 75 games in 2025 but was 101-win playoff-bound two seasons ago, made headlines during the Winter Meetings by signing Mets’ all-time home run leader Pete Alonso to a five-year, $155 million deal. Alonso’s arrival signals that Baltimore is serious about contending in the AL East — and could be preparing to make another blockbuster move.
“I have played on a couple of winning teams,” Alonso told MLB.com. “You need talent, you need young guys. You need a mix of veterans and you need commitment from the top. For me there was no hesitation at all. It’s like, yup, that’s the team. Yup, these are the people. Baltimore is it.”
The question now is whether Baltimore is willing to pair Alonso with Kyle Tucker, a superstar who could transform their lineup from good to elite. Sports business site Spotrac reports Tucker’s expected price tag at $402 million over ten years — a sum that would test even a deep-pocketed organization like the Orioles.
Analyst Jordan Leandre of Just Baseball calls Tucker a “sneaky-good fit” for Baltimore. He points to Tucker’s adaptable hitting style, which allows him to tailor his swing to different ballparks.
“In 2024, Tucker had one of the game’s best pull air rates but maintained a 29.3% oppo air rate. In his one year with the Cubs, he dropped that to 17.5%, keeping elite pull numbers. His batted-ball profile didn’t translate to more home runs at Wrigley or in Camden, but his previous healthy seasons suggest more home run production in Baltimore,” Leandre explained.
Adding Tucker to a lineup that already includes Alonso, Leandre argues, would turn Baltimore into one of the “most lethal lineups on paper” in all of baseball. The combination of established power, young talent, and strategic depth could make the Orioles immediate AL East contenders — a dramatic shift from their modest 75-win season last year.
For the Blue Jays, the pressure is mounting. Their front office has to balance payroll, luxury tax considerations, and the desire to keep core players like Bo Bichette, all while chasing Tucker. Every week that passes without a deal increases the risk that Baltimore — a team many did not expect to challenge for superstar free agents — will strike first.
Toronto’s hesitation could prove costly, as Tucker’s signing would not only strengthen Baltimore but also shift the dynamics of the AL East, potentially complicating Toronto’s path to another championship run.
As 2025 winds to a close, one thing is certain: the race for Kyle Tucker has become the offseason’s defining drama, and the Blue Jays may find themselves outmaneuvered by a team that just months ago seemed unlikely to compete at this level. With a $402 million prize hanging in the balance, the next move could reshape the American League East and set the tone for 2026.
Fans, analysts, and executives alike are now asking: will Toronto act in time, or is Baltimore poised to pull off the offseason’s biggest upset?
Leave a Reply