Kwan’s game relies heavily on speed, defense, and contact hitting rather than power. Reports indicate that his sprint speed dropped from the 80th percentile early in his career to approximately the 35th percentile in 2025. While he remains one of the best defensive left fielders — winning another Gold Glove and recording 22 Defensive Runs Saved — the decline in physical tools could have implications for both base running and range in the outfield.
Despite the speed decline, his elite glove continues to be a major asset. Kwan’s defensive metrics remain top-tier, meaning the Guardians still have an irreplaceable asset in left field, even if offensive contributions have become less predictable.
With these performance trends emerging, trade rumors have resurfaced. Clubs like the Los Angeles Dodgers, San Diego Padres, and Toronto Blue Jays are reportedly interested in acquiring Kwan, attracted by his defensive skills and potential upside. The Guardians now face a strategic dilemma: retain Kwan and hope for a rebound, or trade him while his contract control and defensive reputation make him a valuable asset.
Trading Kwan could net top prospects or MLB-ready talent, potentially addressing offensive or pitching weaknesses. On the other hand, moving him risks leaving the outfield thin and weakening the team’s defensive backbone, forcing the Guardians to rely on untested prospects or make costly acquisitions in free agency.
The decision hinges on several key factors:
-
Offensive needs: If Kwan is traded, the Guardians must replace his on-base presence and steady batting, either with prospects or veterans.
-
Defensive stability: His glove remains elite, meaning losing him could create gaps in left field that are hard to fill.
-
Long-term trajectory: Analysts now question whether Kwan’s recent trend represents a temporary slump or the start of a gradual decline.
Front office insiders suggest that patience may be the prevailing strategy, either extending Kwan’s contract or waiting until trade discussions can maximize return. Either path requires careful balancing of short-term competitiveness with long-term planning.
Steven Kwan stands at a crossroads. Once a sure bet as a franchise cornerstone, subtle declines in speed and offensive output are raising critical questions about his long-term fit. The Guardians must weigh the value of an elite defensive outfielder against the potential for trade returns or the need to shore up other areas of the roster.
This offseason, the organization’s choices regarding Kwan will likely define their strategy, roster construction, and competitiveness for years to come. Cleveland faces a delicate balancing act: preserve defensive excellence and continuity or pivot aggressively to reshape the team for the future.
Leave a Reply