The Blue Jays’ promising 2025 season ended in bitterness: they almost reached the MLB championship, but then lost in a tense Game 7 with their opponent. Now, the consequences are not only the failure — but also the risk of losing key cards. Notably, the solid starting pitcher, who is valued by the media at “$35–45 million” if he hits the open market. Many recent analyses indicate that he may decide to “turn” from the team — with a potential destination being the Padres.
The name that is mentioned most is Chris Bassitt — who had a relatively stable season with an ERA around 3.96, played a key role in the rotation and contributed significantly to the Blue Jays’ World Series.
However, at nearly 37 years old and on a contract that’s about to expire, Bassitt is likely to be offered a hefty market offer—a move that makes his position on the team more precarious than ever.
For the Padres, signing an experienced pitcher like Bassitt is a smart move. MLB experts say they’re looking for a reliable pitcher to fill the void left by their internal turmoil—and Bassitt, with his history of consistency, especially in 2025, fits the bill.
His consistency, ability to throw long innings, and his understanding of postseason pressure make him a much more viable option than the “high risk” players on the market.
If Bassitt does end up going to the Padres, it would be a double blow: the Blue Jays lose a core piece, while the Padres significantly increase their rotation — making them a serious contender as early as 2026.
Losing Bassitt — or any “$45 million star” — would force the Blue Jays to act quickly. They would not only need to find a replacement technically, but also ensure that the rotation is deep enough to survive a long and brutal season. Reserve players, young arms in the farm system — all would be on the table.
In addition, this could affect the team’s long-term mentality and strategy: from “immediate championship contender” to “rebuild and develop sustainably.”
Now, all eyes are on Toronto’s leadership: will they choose to retain their “ace” — at a high price — to maintain their force; or accept losing him, rebuilding the rotation, and finding other solutions? The decision in the coming weeks could determine the direction of the entire organization for the next few years.
With Bassitt in the Padres’ hands—or with the Blue Jays still holding onto him—the winter of 2025–2026 is clearly one of transition, one that could alter the balance of power for more than one team in MLB.
Leave a Reply