Chicago — Cade Horton’s incredible season is sending Cubs fans into a frenzy — but while expectations are high, he’s at risk of being overlooked for National League Rookie of the Year honors. Horton, despite his stellar performance after the All-Star break, could still finish second to fellow Atlanta Braves player Drake Baldwin, according to experts.
“Terrible” numbers — but are they enough?
After the offseason, Horton has the entire MLB looking up: with a 0.93 ERA and a 0.79 WHIP in 11 starts. The numbers aren’t just good — they’re actually beyond what’s expected for a rookie.
But Baldwin — with his season, appearances, and solid stats — is believed by many analysts to be losing less ground with voters.
Why might Horton be snubbed?
Playing Time: Baldwin played almost the entire season—from start to finish—allowing him to accumulate more bWAR, which is a big deal compared to Horton.
Overall Consistency: While Horton has had his share of great games, Baldwin has the advantage of maintaining his form throughout the season—both in big games, tough streaks, and even when faced with pressure.
Public & Media Perception: Baldwin seems to be being built as a “safe” pick for Rookie of the Year voters—a player who appears regularly and contributes consistently. Horton has been much more prominent since the All-Star break, but his starting position before that season has been less talked about.
Cubs & Fan Reaction
Cubs fans have expressed anger and disappointment at the suggestion that Horton might be overlooked. On forums and social media, many tweet that if Horton doesn’t win, it will be one of the judges’ biggest mistakes, because he’s clearly taking his moment for himself.
Not just a trophy — a legacy
For Horton, Rookie of the Year is more than just a medal. It’s a testament: a testament to all the hard work, all the intense moments on the mound, all the sweaty practices, all the strikeouts under the home lights. If he gets snubbed, it will be one of those stories that will be remembered for a long time — fans will talk about “what if…” more than today’s numbers.
Bottom Line: Losing Just One Vote?
While the odds are stacked in Baldwin’s favor in terms of playing time, consistency, and overall contribution, Horton still has a chance — if voters look more broadly, accurately assessing not just what was, but what is, and what could be. But if he doesn’t get Rookie of the Year, baseball fans will talk for days — because Horton has done more than enough to deserve it.
Leave a Reply