Guardians Could Tap Non-Tender Market to Bolster Weak Offense
CLEVELAND — As the 2025 non-tender deadline passed, dozens of formerly controlled players ballooned the free-agent market — and the Guardians may have a real opportunity to use it. With the club’s offense sputtering in recent years and payroll flexibility constrained, non-tendered players offer a potentially high-reward, low-cost fix for Cleveland’s lineup issues.
In MLB terms, “non-tendered” refers to clubs declining to offer a contract to arbitration-eligible players by the winter deadline — immediately turning them into free agents. Teams often make the decision when a player’s projected arbitration raise outweighs his perceived value.
For the Guardians in 2025, the non-tender wave brought several notable names onto the open market — including three former Guardians themselves: outfielder Will Brennan, reliever Sam Hentges, and pitcher Nic Enright. Though Cleveland didn’t re-sign them, the wider class of non-tendered players contains potential fits — especially if the front office targets outfielders or bats with upside.
Why the Timing Could Be Right
The 2025 market is deeper than most realize. As one MLB-wide roundup notes, clubs non-tendered players across positions, including outfielders, corner bats, and bullpen arms.This pool now represents a discount-priced group of veterans and younger players who might thrive with more regular playing time or a change of scenery — qualities that fit well with Cleveland’s current needs.
For a club whose offense has struggled for consistency, non-tendered bats might be a smart bargain. Some available players could offer power potential, platoon balance, or left/right-handed splits that enhance Cleveland’s lineup versatility. The low financial risk makes this especially attractive given budget constraints and recent offseason caution.
What Could Work for Cleveland
-
Mid-tier corner outfielders or designated hitters — looking for a rebound or more opportunity; could provide extra pop without demanding long-term deals.
-
Platoon bats or right-handed hitters — to balance a left-heavy roster and cover for inconsistencies.
-
Depth options and insurance — non-tendered players may accept modest deals and minor-league contracts with upside, giving the Guardians roster flexibility.
Risks & Realities
Non-tendered doesn’t guarantee success. Many such players struggled or dipped the prior season — that’s often why their old clubs let them go. There’s no guarantee they’ll rebound in a new uniform. Also, competition for the more promising non-tendered bats may be fierce, and some teams may outbid Cleveland if their budgets are higher.
Moreover, relying too heavily on bargain signings can backfire. If too many roster spots go to former non-tendered players — or minor-leaguers — lineup depth may remain inconsistent, and performance could suffer.
The Verdict — A Smart Risk, If Managed Well
For a franchise like the Guardians — looking to compete without overspending — the non-tender market offers a real, if modest, chance to upgrade offense. It won’t be a silver bullet, but carefully chosen additions could provide meaningful gains: better balance, occasional power, and flexibility.
If Cleveland’s front office acts decisively — surveying the pool, identifying undervalued bats, and offering short-term, incentive-heavy deals — the non-tender market could provide the missing link between a proud pitching legacy and a competitive, well-rounded lineup. The door’s open. The talent is out there. It’s up to Cleveland to step through it.
Leave a Reply