Shortly after the season ended, social media and some unofficial news sites began to spread rumors that Jeff Hoffman – a notable rookie of the Toronto Blue Jays – was “put on the trading table” by the team after his performance in the World Series was not as expected. The rumor quickly attracted attention because Hoffman was considered one of the strongest pitchers that the Blue Jays owned in the 2024 season.
However, when verified by reputable sources such as MLB.com, TSN, Yahoo Sports, the actual picture was completely different: Hoffman was not for sale, but on the contrary – he just signed a 3-year contract worth 33 million USD, with a bonus that could reach 39 million, and was expected to become an important pitcher in Toronto’s bullpen.
Before joining Toronto, Hoffman had attracted public attention when the Baltimore Orioles and Atlanta Braves withdrew from negotiations due to concerns related to his throwing shoulder. But after joining the Blue Jays, Hoffman immediately reassured fans, asserting that the medical reports “do not reflect his true feelings.”
The Blue Jays not only believe the 31-year-old pitcher’s words, but also the statistics:
Last season’s ERA was below 2.50
High strikeout rate
Prestigious late-game pitching ability
That’s why Toronto gave him a role that could become an official closer in the early stages of the 2025 season.
So where did the trade rumors come from?
According to many analysts, the rumors emerged from:
A few controversial games in the playoffs – easily exaggerated.
The Blue Jays have many pitchers competing for a similar role, such as Romano, Green and Swanson.
Unreliable news sites that specialize in “rumors” attract readers, easily creating a false impression.
Several veteran MLB reporters have flatly dismissed the reports, insisting there’s no indication Toronto is looking to part ways with Hoffman just weeks after signing him to a big contract.
What the Blue Jays Say?
While the team hasn’t made a direct statement, the team’s actions have sent a clear message:
Hoffman isn’t just leaving the team — he’s part of their grand plan.
Toronto is prioritizing building a strong playoff-caliber bullpen, and Hoffman is a central piece of that plan.
Jeff Hoffman is not currently in the running for a trade. On the contrary, he’ll be a key player as the Blue Jays enter the new season with postseason ambitions.
While the rumors continue to swirl, one thing is almost certain:
Toronto didn’t spend $33–39 million just to let Hoffman go after a month.
Leave a Reply