Few players in today’s MLB landscape embody the combination of skill, competitiveness, and reliability quite like José Ramírez. Season after season, the Guardians’ switch-hitting third baseman proves he belongs among baseball’s elite. And yet, despite an extraordinary résumé that surpasses several MVP winners, Ramírez still has not secured the award himself — a reality that has turned him into one of the most intriguing “non-MVP legends” in modern baseball.
Ramírez’s 2025 season was another testament to his remarkable consistency. Across 158 games, he delivered a .283 batting average, a .360 on-base percentage, and a .503 slugging percentage. He hammered 30 home runs, drove in 85 runs, totaled 34 doubles, and stole 44 bases — the highest stolen-base mark of his career. Few players can produce this kind of power-speed combination, and even fewer do it year after year without decline. What keeps making Ramírez stand out is that this isn’t a one-year outlier — it’s who he has been since 2017.
His value becomes even clearer when considering his wins above replacement (WAR), where he has repeatedly ranked among the league’s top players. Since breaking out nearly a decade ago, Ramírez has posted six seasons with at least 5.5 WAR — a level typically associated with MVP winners or finalists. Yet for Ramírez, this has become routine, even as the Guardians have gone through roster changes, offensive slumps, and competitive ups and downs.
Despite all this, the MVP trophy has remained just out of reach. Ramírez has finished in the top five of MVP voting six times, tying the historical record for the most top-five finishes without winning. He also holds the record for the most top-three finishes by a non-winner. In 2025, he finished third, trailing only Aaron Judge and Cal Raleigh — both of whom had career years that created exceptionally competitive voting totals. Ramírez’s situation often reflects timing misfortune more than a lack of merit.
This theme repeats throughout his career. When he had MVP-caliber seasons in the late 2010s, he competed directly with all-time performances from players like Mike Trout and Mookie Betts. In recent years, he has overlapped with historic two-way dominance from Shohei Ohtani and explosive, headline-grabbing seasons from Judge. In nearly any other era, Ramírez would likely already have at least one MVP trophy — perhaps more. Instead, his career narrative has become a case study in how individual awards often depend on timing, team success, and statistical spectacle.
But Ramírez’s greatness extends far beyond MVP debates. He represents a rare type of superstar: consistent but not flashy, humble but intensely competitive, and elite in multiple dimensions of the game. He is one of the few modern players capable of producing 30-home-run, 40-steal seasons. He rarely slumps, rarely misses significant time, and rarely fails to deliver in high-leverage moments. Even on Guardians teams that have struggled offensively, he has remained a stabilizing force — the player opponents fear and teammates rely on.
As Ramírez enters the next phase of his career, the question naturally returns: will he ever win the long-awaited MVP? At 33, he remains remarkably productive, and if he keeps performing at elite levels, the opportunity remains open. But even if the award never comes, his legacy is already secure. Few players in baseball history have maintained such a high level of excellence for such a long period, especially without the support of stacked lineups or big-market attention.
In the end, whether he earns the trophy or not, José Ramírez’s career stands as one defined not by awards, but by sustained greatness. And sometimes, that speaks louder than any single season’s accolade.
Leave a Reply