Max Scherzer’s Bold Call to Rank Umpires Could Spark a New Era in MLB
Max Scherzer has built his reputation on pinpoint command, a fierce competitive streak, and an unrelenting pursuit of excellence. Now, he’s aiming that same energy at one of baseball’s most scrutinized elements: umpiring. After a recent outing with the Texas Rangers, the three-time Cy Young Award winner issued a statement that could ignite a seismic shift in Major League Baseball. Scherzer is calling for the league to introduce a formal ranking system for umpires using electronic strike zone technology and to consider relegating the lowest-performing officials to the minor leagues.
“Let the electronic strike zone rank the umpires,” Scherzer said. “We need to have a conversation about the bottom—let’s call it 10 percent—and talk about relegating those umpires.”
It was a candid critique from one of MLB’s most respected veterans, and it quickly set off a firestorm across the league. For years, fans and analysts have debated missed calls, inconsistent strike zones, and the slow adoption of technology in baseball. Scherzer’s remarks, however, put a respected voice behind a growing chorus demanding change.
Players have long been frustrated with questionable calls, especially in high-leverage situations, but public criticism of umpires from active stars remains rare. Scherzer’s willingness to speak out reflects a shift in the culture of the game, where technology is no longer viewed as a threat but as a necessary tool for accountability. Statcast data and pitch-tracking software have already made strike zone discrepancies impossible to ignore, and the Automated Ball-Strike System (ABS) is being tested in Triple-A with promising results.
While some players and managers support Scherzer’s call for reform, the proposal could face stiff resistance from the umpires’ union. MLB’s umpires have long been protected by collective bargaining agreements, and relegation would mark a significant departure from how the league has historically treated its officials. Critics argue that ranking and demoting umpires could create a culture of fear, eroding relationships between players, coaches, and umpires.
Still, Scherzer’s comments resonate at a time when fans demand transparency and precision. Social media amplifies every blown call, and the league has been exploring ways to improve officiating consistency. In that sense, Scherzer’s outburst may be less a rant and more a reflection of where the sport is heading.
As baseball continues to evolve, the conversation surrounding umpiring is unlikely to fade. If anything, Scherzer has added fuel to a movement already underway. The Rangers ace, now 39, has seen just about everything in his two-decade career. His willingness to advocate for systemic change suggests that even baseball’s most traditional elements are not immune to innovation.
Whether MLB embraces Scherzer’s vision remains to be seen. For now, his comments have sparked a league-wide debate that transcends team rivalries and touches the heart of baseball’s identity. The strike zone, long a subject of interpretation, could one day be standardized by machines. And if Scherzer gets his way, the men behind the plate will be held to the same rigorous standards as the players they judge.
Leave a Reply