A controversial voting season is underway as the finalists for the 2025 Hank Aaron Award – an award that honors the best offensive player in MLB – have just been announced. Familiar names like Shohei Ohtani, Aaron Judge, Juan Soto, Vladimir Guerrero Jr., and Fernando Tatis Jr. are all on the ballot, but that is what makes fans and experts unable to agree on who is truly worthy.
The Power Race Between the Two Leagues
In the American League, three prominent names are leading the debate:
Aaron Judge (Yankees) – a two-time winner of this award and having a “killing” season with over 50 HR.
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (Blue Jays) – a symbol of youth and Canadian spirit, returns strongly after a turbulent 2024 season.
Byron Buxton (Twins) – a surprise “dark horse”, with an explosive series of games that has caught the attention of the entire MLB.
Meanwhile, in the National League, the story is no less intense:
Shohei Ohtani (Dodgers) – is rewriting history with his record of both pitching and hitting, but many believe that his two-way play has “skewed” the fairness criteria of the league.
Juan Soto (Phillies) – stable performance, impressive offensive stats, and is the most favorite face of analysts.
Fernando Tatis Jr. (Padres) – a controversial return after events, but his burning performance still gives him a chance to win the title.
The big question: “The award for strength or for comprehensiveness?”
Many experts believe that the Hank Aaron Award is losing its “pure offensive spirit” as the criteria for judging become more expansive than ever. Some reporters even believe that Ohtani’s inclusion in the list could make the outcome pre-determined – because no one can compete with a player who is both a slugger and an effective pitcher.
However, fans of Judge and Soto argue: “If this is an award for a ball destroyer, then Ohtani should not be given priority for his pitching record.”
On social media, from New York to Tokyo, thousands of comments have erupted with the same question:
“Between pure power and all-around talent, which is the true spirit of Hank Aaron?”
A dramatic voting season awaits
The final results will be announced after the World Series, but for now, all eyes are on three names: Ohtani, Judge and Guerrero Jr. – who not only dominate the stat sheet but also divide the baseball world with their own style.
As one MLB analyst put it succinctly on ESPN:
“This year’s Hank Aaron Award – the man who made the swing iconic – will honor not just a bat, but a revolution.”
The question now is not who wins, but whether the baseball world can still agree on the definition of greatness…
Leave a Reply