The 2025 campaign was a rocky one for catcher Bo Naylor. On paper, his batting line — .195 average, .282 on‑base, .379 slugging — translated to an 85 wRC+. But dig a little deeper, and there are signs that Naylor could be rebuilding toward something more promising.
Naylor made some encouraging adjustments this year. His strikeout rate dropped more than 7 percentage points from the prior season — going from 31.4% down to 23.9%. Meanwhile, his walk rate climbed to 10.9%. That combination — fewer whiffs and more free passes — suggests he worked on plate discipline and contact approach, rather than selling out for power.
The second half of 2025 showed flashes of a turnaround. After changing his batting stance (switching from a leg‑lift to a toe‑tap), Naylor’s results improved noticeably. He slashed .232/.295/.432 overall after the adjustment — good for a 98 wRC+ in that span — then surged even more in the final month, posting a 136 wRC+. His line-drive and “sweet spot” contact rates also rose, hinting he’s making better, more consistent contact — not just swinging harder.
It wasn’t just the timing that looked better: Naylor also showed an ability to deliver in clutch moments. On September 14, he came up big against the Chicago White Sox — driving in all three runs in a 3‑2 win via a seventh‑inning go-ahead home run, having earlier added a two‑run double to help secure the series sweep. In another late‑season game, Naylor racked up four RBIs, tying a career high and helping push the Cleveland Guardians closer to the wild‑card race.
Still, the season wasn’t without its problems. Overall offensive output remained well below what’s expected from a major‑league regular. Defense — a major part of a catcher’s value — was inconsistent. Reports suggest that his pitch framing, once a strong suit, regressed significantly in 2025, even though he improved in blocking and throwing out runners. Given emerging internal catching prospects and growing organizational pressure, the upcoming season could be a make‑or‑break one for him.
Still, Naylor remains young and has shown he’s willing to adjust. The improvements in contact quality, walk rate, and situational hitting — especially late in the season — offer hope that he might inch closer to the form that made him a top prospect. For the Guardians, the options are clear: stick with Naylor and hope the adjustments carry over into consistent performance — or seek alternatives behind the plate if they decide 2026 must be better. Either way, 2025 was a season of turbulence — not triumph, but not failure either. It might just be the reset that Bo Naylor needs.
Leave a Reply