What was supposed to be the most hopeful day of John Means’ professional life instead became one of the cruelest twists baseball can deliver.
Former Cleveland Guardians and Baltimore Orioles pitcher John Means announced Tuesday that he ruptured his Achilles tendon on the very same day he was scheduled to sign an MLB contract, abruptly halting a comeback that had taken more than four years to reach the brink of reality. The news, confirmed by Means himself in an emotional Instagram post, sent a wave of shock and sympathy across the baseball world.
“This is hard to put into words, but I’ll try,” Means wrote. “On Tuesday, while training, I ruptured my Achilles. It happened the same day I was supposed to sign with a team and be available on Opening Day for the first time in a long time.”
For Means, 32, the timing was devastating beyond comprehension.
After undergoing Tommy John surgery in June 2024, the left-hander spent the entire 2025 MLB season in recovery. The long rehab process tested not only his arm but his patience, faith, and belief that his career still had meaningful chapters left. According to those close to him, this offseason was different. For the first time in years, his body felt whole again.
“I was finally enjoying my first healthy offseason in four years and felt better than ever,” Means wrote. “Yesterday, I underwent successful surgery with Dr. Vopat and his incredible team. I don’t know why this happened or how this chapter will ultimately be used, but I know it’s now part of my story and God has a plan.”
The injury reportedly occurred during routine training, not in a game or high-risk workout. Just one moment — a sudden rupture — erased months of progress and an imminent return to Major League Baseball. The identity of the team prepared to sign Means has not been disclosed, but league sources confirmed the deal was expected to be finalized that day, positioning Means to be available for Opening Day for the first time since his initial elbow injury.
Instead, he found himself in a hospital bed.
Means spent the 2025 season with the Cleveland Guardians, though he never appeared in a Major League game for the club. Cleveland signed him while he was rehabbing from surgery, hoping the former All-Star could eventually contribute or at least rebuild value. Late in the season, Means made seven minor league rehab appearances with High-A Lake County and Triple-A Columbus, logging 26.2 innings.
The results were understandably uneven: a 6.08 ERA, 1.27 WHIP, and 22 strikeouts. But evaluators were less focused on the stat line and more encouraged by his health, velocity, and ability to compete again on a mound. Those flashes were enough to draw interest around the league once Cleveland declined its 2026 team option in November, officially making Means a free agent.
The plan was simple: sign, report, and finally move forward.
Instead, the setback adds another brutal chapter to a career already defined by perseverance.
Means debuted with the Baltimore Orioles in 2018 and quickly emerged as one of the organization’s brightest pitching stars. In 2019, he earned an All-Star selection and finished second in American League Rookie of the Year voting, establishing himself as a dependable, high-IQ left-hander with elite command and poise.
Over seven seasons with Baltimore (2018–2024), Means compiled a 23–26 record, a 3.68 ERA, a remarkable 1.05 WHIP, and 334 strikeouts across 401 innings. While his win-loss record never reflected his effectiveness, his consistency and competitiveness made him a trusted arm at the top of the Orioles’ rotation before injuries intervened.
Now, the Achilles rupture introduces a new layer of uncertainty — particularly daunting for a pitcher already returning from major elbow surgery. Recovery timelines for Achilles injuries can stretch well beyond a year, and teams will understandably approach cautiously.
Yet those close to Means insist his mindset remains intact.
Baseball history is filled with stories of careers altered — and sometimes reborn — by moments like this. What makes Means’ situation especially painful is the precision of the timing. He didn’t get hurt mid-season. He didn’t get hurt chasing a comeback. He got hurt on the day he had already won — the day the contract was waiting.
In a sport that often speaks about resilience, few examples are as stark.
For now, John Means’ return is postponed, not erased. The road ahead will be long, uncertain, and physically demanding. But if his career has proven anything, it’s that survival in baseball isn’t always about velocity or durability — sometimes it’s about refusing to let the worst day define the final chapter.
The contract didn’t get signed.
The comeback didn’t happen.
But the story, heartbreakingly, isn’t over yet.
Leave a Reply