From Sea Dogs to Fenway Dreams: Connelly Early and Payton Tolle Make a Double Leap to the Big Leagues
BOSTON — For Connelly Early and Payton Tolle, the road to Fenway Park has been a season-long sprint filled with late-night bus rides, cramped minor league clubhouses, and relentless work. This week, the two pitchers who began the year as teammates with the Double-A Portland Sea Dogs achieved what most players can only imagine: a shared promotion to the Boston Red Sox.
Their story began last spring in the quiet corners of Portland’s Hadlock Field, where Early and Tolle quickly bonded over bullpen sessions and postgame meals. Early, a left-hander with a deceptive fastball, and Tolle, a sturdy righty known for his heavy sinker, developed a friendship built on mutual drive. “We were always pushing each other,” Early recalled before Tuesday’s game. “Every side session, every workout, it was about making the next day better.”
That competitive partnership paid off. Early dominated Eastern League hitters with pinpoint command, while Tolle racked up strikeouts and ground balls in equal measure. Scouts praised their poise as much as their pitches, and by midseason, Boston’s front office had taken notice. When injuries opened two spots on the big-league staff, the call went out—and fittingly, it came for both.
“We got the call almost at the same time,” Tolle said with a grin. “I was packing when I heard Connelly was heading up too. It felt like a dream.”
The pair arrived at Fenway Park together, wide-eyed but ready. During their first bullpen session under the shadow of the Green Monster, veteran catcher Connor Wong offered a few quiet tips, while manager Alex Cora watched with a smile. “It’s rare to bring up two guys who are already comfortable working as a team,” Cora noted. “That chemistry can be a real asset.”
In their debut appearances, Early tossed two scoreless innings of relief, flashing the fastball-slider combo that made him a prospect to watch, while Tolle induced a double play to escape a jam in the seventh. The crowd responded with a standing ovation usually reserved for veterans, sensing the promise these rookies carry.
Off the field, their connection continues. They share an apartment near Fenway and still trade scouting notes over late-night meals. “We’re both here to learn,” Early said. “Having a friend next to you makes everything a little less overwhelming.”
Red Sox fans are eager to see how the duo might impact the club’s pitching plans. With Boston jockeying for a postseason berth, fresh arms with fearless mindsets are a welcome addition. For Early and Tolle, though, the moment is about gratitude and possibility. “This is everything we’ve worked for,” Tolle said. “But it’s just the beginning.”
As they walked out of the clubhouse after their first win as major leaguers, the two paused to take in the lights of Fenway. “We’ll remember this night forever,” Early said quietly. “Now it’s time to keep earning it.”
Leave a Reply