Three Potential Replacements for Javonte Williams if He Leaves in Free Agency — Who Will Be the Cowboys’ RB1 Next Season?
By LP Cruz | December 29, 2025 – 9:00 AM PST
As the 2025 NFL season winds down, one of the biggest unanswered questions surrounding the Dallas Cowboys centers on the running back position. With Javonte Williams expected to test free agency, Dallas could be facing yet another major transition in its backfield. After a season defined by inconsistency, injuries, and flashes of potential, the Cowboys must decide whether to re-sign Williams—or pivot toward a new RB1 for 2026.
If Williams does walk, the Cowboys will have options. Some are familiar. Others would represent a bold change in philosophy. Here are three realistic replacements for Javonte Williams—and a deeper look at who could ultimately emerge as Dallas’ RB1 next season.
1. Tony Pollard (Internal Option, If Retained on a Short Deal)
Yes, the obvious name still matters.
Even if Javonte Williams leaves, the Cowboys could choose continuity by leaning back toward Tony Pollard, assuming he remains on the roster or returns on a team-friendly deal. Pollard’s explosiveness, pass-catching ability, and familiarity with the offense make him a natural bridge option—especially if Dallas isn’t ready to hand the backfield to a rookie.
Pollard is no longer viewed as a classic workhorse, but that may actually work in his favor. In a more balanced committee, Pollard can thrive as a 12–15 touch-per-game weapon rather than a 20+ carry grinder.
Pros:
- Knows the system
- Explosive in space
- Proven chemistry with Dak Prescott
Cons:
- Durability concerns
- Not ideal as a pure power RB
If Pollard stays, he may not dominate touches—but he could still open 2026 as the de facto RB1.
2. Draft Pick RB (The Long-Term Answer)
If history tells us anything, it’s that the Cowboys aren’t afraid to invest premium draft capital at running back when they believe in the talent.
With a strong 2026 RB draft class looming, Dallas could target a young, cost-controlled back who fits their identity: physical, decisive, and capable of handling early-down work. A rookie wouldn’t just replace Javonte Williams—they’d reset the entire backfield timeline.
This option becomes even more attractive if Dallas wants to balance the salary cap while preparing for future extensions at quarterback, wide receiver, and on defense.
Why this makes sense:
- RB contracts are cheaper on rookie deals
- Fresh legs, no injury baggage
- Opportunity to redefine the offense
The downside? Rookie running backs often struggle with pass protection and consistency early on—something that could frustrate a win-now roster.
Still, if the Cowboys draft a back in Rounds 1–3, that player would immediately be the favorite to become RB1 by midseason, even if the year begins as a committee.
3. Veteran Free Agent Power Back (The “Stability” Move)
If Dallas loses Javonte Williams and doesn’t love the draft board, a veteran free agent could be the answer. This would likely be a short-term, physical runner—someone who can handle goal-line work, protect the quarterback, and grind out tough yards.
This type of signing wouldn’t be flashy, but it would signal that Dallas values reliability over upside.
Think of a back who complements Pollard or a rookie rather than replaces them outright.
Why the Cowboys might go this route:
- Immediate experience
- Leadership in the locker room
- Insurance against injuries
The risk? Limited ceiling. A veteran RB might stabilize the offense but won’t dramatically elevate it.
So… Who Will Be RB1 for the Cowboys in 2026?
The most likely answer: no one single player dominates the role.
If Javonte Williams leaves, the Cowboys appear headed toward a committee approach, with early-down work split between a rookie or veteran power back and Pollard handling explosive and passing situations.
That said, if Dallas drafts a running back early, expect that player to take over RB1 duties by November.
Best Guess Scenario
- Early season: Pollard + rookie/FA split
- Midseason: Rookie becomes primary runner
- Red zone: Veteran or power back rotation
This approach aligns with modern NFL trends and allows Dallas to stay flexible while protecting players from overuse.
Final Thoughts
Javonte Williams’ potential departure isn’t just about replacing a name on the depth chart—it’s about redefining how the Cowboys run the football. Whether they lean on youth, familiarity, or veteran stability, one thing is clear: Dallas is entering another transition at running back.
And until that transition settles, the RB1 job will remain one of the most fascinating battles to watch heading into the 2026 season.
Leave a Reply