After a turbulent 2025 season, the Blue Jays are under pressure to strengthen their roster — especially their “pitching weapons.” This season, despite the presence of veteran names like Max Scherzer and Kevin Gausman, the team still clearly shows signs of a lack of depth and stability in the rotation.
Therefore, finding another “ace” with high performance is the top priority of the leadership. And according to many analyzes, the prominent name that Toronto is aiming for is Dylan Cease — currently on the Padres payroll, is one of the most notable free throwers this season.
Cease is famous for his strong throwing power, impressive “strikeout” ability, and has had many excellent starting seasons. While 2025 has been a challenging season for him — his results have been disappointing — metrics like xFIP still suggest that many experts believe Cease is more “unlucky” than a decline in his ability, making him an attractive recovery candidate.
If the Jays were to sign Cease, he could slot into the No. 2 or No. 3 pitching lineup — right behind Gausman — to form a formidable trio that could threaten any opponent in the postseason. That’s what many fans and experts see as Toronto’s “secret weapon” next season.
However, the risk cannot be ignored. Cease hasn’t really “settled down” after a tumultuous season; if he doesn’t find his form, betting on him could backfire, exposing his rotation weaknesses.
With his current salary cap and financial resources, the Blue Jays could definitely make a deal. But the bigger question is: are they willing to take the risk for a big opportunity?
If successful, the team will have a “top” rotation — strong in terms of pitching, consistency, and strikeout ability — which will give them a huge advantage in the championship race.
If unsuccessful, it will be an investment that can become a burden, especially when other members of the bullpen and offense also need to be strengthened equally.
A “safer” option for the Blue Jays might be to target more consistent pitchers (as in top free agent lists), to ensure depth without putting too much on a single player.
The 2026 trade season promises to be a period of great change for the Blue Jays. If they decide to sign Dylan Cease — or another “ace” — it will be a clear signal of their championship ambitions: they are no longer just building a squad, but are going all in to “bet big.” But as with any gamble, the opportunity and the risk go hand in hand.
For Toronto fans—and all MLB fans—this will be one of the most exciting winters to watch. Will the Jays succeed in stealing an ace from their rival, or will it be a huge miss? The answer will become clear as the rumors become reality—or just wishful thinking.
Leave a Reply