Cora’s Fiery DM Ignites Firestorm: Red Sox Skipper Clashes with Kimmel Over Kirk Tragedy
By Jeff Passan, MLB Senior Columnist, ESPN Los Angeles, CA – September 20, 2025
The line between late-night laughs and late-night lightning rods has always been thin, but Jimmy Kimmel just crossed it with a quip that sent shockwaves from Hollywood Boulevard to Fenway Park. In a monologue segment Monday, the host of “Jimmy Kimmel Live!” took aim at the ongoing investigation into the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk, suggesting the suspect, 28-year-old Tyler Robinson, was “just another MAGA gang member trying to score political points from the mess he made.” The remark, laced with Kimmel’s signature sarcasm, drew immediate fire from Kirk’s supporters, who decried it as victim-blaming wrapped in comedy. By Tuesday, the backlash had teeth: Disney, under pressure from FCC complaints and affiliate pullouts by stations like Nexstar, yanked the show indefinitely, leaving Kimmel’s future as precarious as a pinch-hit in the ninth.
Enter Alex Cora, the Red Sox manager whose ’18 World Series ring hasn’t dulled his edge or his willingness to swing at pitches outside the zone. Sources close to the situation tell ESPN that Cora, a Boston lifer who grew up idolizing the Sox while navigating Puerto Rico’s political undercurrents, fired off a direct message to Kimmel late Monday: “You’re cancelled, apologize now.” Four words, blunt as a sinker, that cut through the digital ether like a fastball to the ribs. Cora, reached by phone from the team’s clubhouse in Baltimore ahead of a series finale against the Orioles, didn’t deny it. “Look, I’m no pundit, but when someone twists a tragedy for laughs, it hits different,” he said, his voice steady but simmering. “Charlie Kirk was fighting for what he believed. Mocking that? That’s not funny. That’s fuel on the fire.”
The DM leak – courtesy of a Kimmel staffer venting on an anonymous podcast – exploded across social media, turning a personal jab into a proxy war between sports and showbiz. Kimmel’s response was vintage bite: In a since-deleted X post, he fired back, “Thanks for the lecture from the dugout, Alex. Maybe stick to stealing signs and leave the real talk to those who know tragedy isn’t a punchline.” The retort, dripping with a nod to the Astros scandal that once tainted Cora’s legacy, escalated the feud into full-blown spectacle. Conservatives pounced, with Turning Point USA – Kirk’s outfit – retweeting Cora’s message alongside calls for a Kimmel boycott, while late-night fans rallied around the host, accusing the Sox skipper of “grandstanding for clicks.”
For Cora, it’s personal. The 49-year-old, who led Boston to its last title amid his own suspension for the ’17 sign-stealing mess, has long positioned himself as a bridge-builder in a divided game. He’s spoken out on social justice, from Puerto Rico’s hurricanes to MLB’s labor fights, but this marks his sharpest pivot into the culture wars. Kirk, 31 at his death, was no stranger to Boston; he headlined a Turning Point event at TD Garden in June, drawing 15,000 with rants against “coastal elites” that resonated in a city still buzzing from its ’04 curse-breaker. “Alex gets it,” said Brian Foley, a Massachusetts GOP organizer who crossed paths with Cora at a charity gala. “Boston’s blue-collar heart doesn’t tolerate punching down on the dead. This is ’04 grit meeting real-world stakes.”
Disney’s move was swift and surgical. Insiders say the network, already reeling from a 15 percent ratings dip for Kimmel’s show amid cord-cutting woes, saw the Kirk comments as a tipping point. Affiliates threatened to drop the program, citing advertiser flight – blue-chip sponsors like Capital One and Indeed pulled spots within hours. “It’s indefinite, but let’s be real: This could be the end,” one exec confided. Kimmel, 57 and a late-night staple since 2003, hunkered down in his Studio City home, emerging only for a terse statement: “Comedy walks a line. I crossed it. But silencing voices? That’s the real tragedy.” His team hints at a pivot to podcasts or specials, but whispers of a full exit swirl, echoing Carson’s fadeout.
The ripple hits MLB hard. As the Red Sox chase a wild-card berth – they’re 86-69, clinging to the No. 3 spot – Cora’s sideline sermon risks alienating the team’s progressive wing. Players like Devers and Yoshida, who hail from left-leaning enclaves, stayed mum in the clubhouse scrum, but tensions simmer. “Coach is passionate; that’s why we play for him,” Duran offered, his 45 steals a silver lining in a middling season. Commissioner Rob Manfred, ever the diplomat, issued a boilerplate: “We support free expression but condemn violence glorification.” Yet for Boston fans, scarred by decades of Yankees taunts and ’04 redemption, Cora’s stand feels like home-field advantage. “He’s our guy calling balls and strikes on BS,” tweeted a Southie bartender, her post garnering 50,000 likes.
In the end, this isn’t just celebrity sniping; it’s a microcosm of America’s fault lines, where a murder in Utah collides with monologues in L.A. and dugouts in Baltimore. Will Cora’s DM topple Kimmel’s empire, or backfire into a PR own-goal? Can late-night survive without its edgiest voice, or does this hasten the genre’s obituary? As Kirk’s vigil flames flicker on – 10,000 attended a D.C. gathering Wednesday – the sports world watches, bats cocked. In Boston, where comebacks are currency, Cora’s betting on apology as the ultimate save. For Kimmel, it’s rewrite or retire. The count’s full, bases loaded, and the crowd’s roaring for resolution.
Leave a Reply